This issue - The Summertime Blues Report


Summer is almost over and the bill is on the counter. 600 Microsoft employees built their own pay spreadsheet because the company deleted the question. 1 in 5 of the jobs you applied to was never real. The chief executives who outperform everybody had the hardest time getting hired. Loopio's chief people officer did the thing everybody else put on a panel. And the scariest book I read all summer explains who benefits from the rest of it. Turn it up. 🔊


🎧 This issue's theme song
"Summertime Blues" — Eddie Cochran
1958. A kid works all summer, asks the boss for 2 days off and gets told no. Asks his congressman. Takes it to the United Nations. And the last line has been ringing in my ears all month: I'd like to help you son, but you're too young to vote. Every institution in that song has an answer ready and none of them is yes. Every story has its own track and this one is loud. 🎶

Everybody asked. Nobody answered.

I read this month back to back and the same thing happens in every story. A person asks, and the building says nothing.

A woman in Austin has applied for more than 3,000 jobs since May of last year and burned through $40,000 in savings, and 19% of the ads she was answering showed no hiring activity after they took the applications. Microsoft removed the compensation question from its own survey, so 600 employees built a spreadsheet themselves. 24% of employees got no training at all this year and over half heard from their manager once.

And underneath it, a book that came out on the 18th explaining that a small group of people funding a great deal of this has decided the asking part was the problem.

One person in this issue answered, so Joanna Kmiec goes first.

From Kristy 💌

Lance and I disagreed in public and it made the argument better

3 deals landed in 7 days. Lattice bought Pando. Silver Lake opened talks to take Workday private. And Google bid $10 million for the email of an airline that no longer flies, with Mercor counter-bidding $7.5 million, which means somebody negotiated over it.

I emailed Lance Haun the morning the Pando news broke and told him all 3 were the same deal. He agreed, then told me I had the reason backwards. His argument is that the pricing page decided everything, because per-employee pricing is a tax on a headcount number that stopped going up. Mine is that ownership decides, because the owner chooses between stewardship and an exit, and the employee whose record it is has no standing in either.

The Spirit Airlines lot is the part that should stay with you. Roughly 175,000 employee records dating back to 1986, 100 million emails, 500 million Teams messages. A labor union objected. That is the complete list of who objected.

Neither of us moved the other. That is rather the point, and it is why the piece is worth your 9 minutes instead of another 1,000 words of agreement.

🎧 Track: “Cruel Summer” — Bananarama, 1983.

In this issue 📋

01 · Joanna Kmiec put people and technology in the same seat
02 · Microsoft deleted the pay question, so 600 people built the answer
03 · 1 in 5 job ads was never real, and lawmakers finally noticed
04 · They outperform because the door was heavier
05 · The scariest book I read all summer
06 · Still grading last year while this year gets away from us
+ · Quick hits, field notes for every seat, and 13 tracks

01 — The one doing it right ☀️

Joanna Kmiec put people and technology in the same seat

Every conference this year had a panel about the CHRO becoming a business leader. Joanna Kmiec, chief people officer at Loopio in Toronto, roughly 220 people, went and did it. She merged the people function with technology, had the transformation team report to her, put engagement in as a corporate-level metric, and started measuring time to productivity. She describes it as one of the most ambitious changes in the company's history, done at a pace a conventional structure would have made impossible.

“Trust in leadership, trust in HR, and maintaining that through a lot of change. Once you lose that, it impacts more metrics than I believe leadership really gives it credit for.”

— Joanna Kmiec, Chief People Officer, Loopio

My take: 2 things here are stealable this week. The reporting line is the first. Putting transformation under the people leader means the tooling decision and the change decision get made by the same person, which removes about half the reasons a rollout fails. The second is that she named trust as the thing to protect and said it moves more metrics than leadership credits. She is right, and the reason most executives will not act on it is that trust has never had a number attached, so it loses every argument against a number that does. Give it one. That is the whole job for the next 2 years.

📄 HRD Canada → · Jeffrey R. Smith, August 21.

🎧 Track: “Here Comes the Sun” — The Beatles, 1969.

02 — The spreadsheet 💰

Microsoft deleted the pay question, so 600 people built the answer

Microsoft dropped the compensation question from its internal employee survey. Employees responded by crowdsourcing an anonymous pay spreadsheet, roughly 600 submissions out of about 223,000 people worldwide, and Business Insider published the numbers.

What it shows is a company split in 2. In Cloud, base salaries run from $111,000 to $450,000 and annual stock awards from $9,000 to $1.4 million. Over in Xbox, base pay tops out around $218,000. Company-wide, reported raises this year ran from 0% to 3.5%. This is the 3rd time employees have done this. 1,200 did it in 2021, more than 850 in 2025, 600 this month. Microsoft declined to comment.

Same badge, same cafeteria, and a stock award that differs by a factor of 150 depending on which side of the building your product sits on.

My take: A crowdsourced spreadsheet is what an organization gets instead of a pay philosophy. These get built when the official channel closes, and the moment a company removes a question from its own survey it has told every employee exactly what the answer would have been. 2 things to do. Check whether any question disappeared from your engagement survey this cycle and who approved it, because that deletion is a communication whether you meant it as one or not. Then go find your own 2-tier problem, because you have one. Somebody is doing hard work in a division nobody writes headlines about, on a raise between 0% and 3.5%, watching another team get restricted stock. They are not confused about their value. They are doing the math.

🎧 Track: “Money” — Pink Floyd, 1973.

03 — The ghost town 👻

1 in 5 of those jobs was never real

Lauren Weber reported it in the Journal on the 21st. Greenhouse looked at digital job boards in Q2 and found 19% of advertised jobs showed no meaningful hiring activity after taking applications, with no test reviews and no interviews scheduled. Employers have their reasons. Pipeline building, a dream candidate, slow removal after an opening was rescinded, board visibility during a freeze, harvesting applicant data, signaling growth to investors. Every one of those is a reason to run an ad, and not one of them is a job.

“If you've posted a job and you have 500 applicants, are you telling me not one or two or three are qualified? Are you looking for a unicorn? Or is it not a real job?”

— Heather Sanford, 44, in Austin. 3,000+ applications since May 2025, $40,000 of savings gone, and she is planning to move.

Legislatures finally moved. New York passed a bill through both houses requiring disclosure of expected hiring timelines, with fines attached, now waiting on the governor. Pennsylvania has a bill requiring accurate hiring intentions and a deadline for pulling filled postings. Texas has an attorney general investigating LinkedIn over profiting from fake ads.

My take: We spent a decade building candidate experience programs, hiring people to run them, and putting the phrase on career sites in a nice font. Then a fifth of the market started advertising jobs that did not exist and it took a state legislature to say something. Heather Sanford applied 3,000 times and spent her savings answering ads. Some meaningful share of those were nobody's job. Before New York's bill reaches you as a compliance memo, pull every posting your company has live and check it against a real requisition. You will find some. Take them down this week and you get to say you did it because it was right rather than because it became illegal.

📄 WSJ → · Lauren Weber, August 21.

🎧 Track: “Ghost Town” — The Specials, 1981.

04 — The threshold 🪜

They outperform because the door was heavier

4 researchers at Concordia and Bryant looked at 11,605 firm-year observations of large public American companies from 1998 to 2013. Best performers were racialized women, then white women, then racialized men. Worst performers were white men, who were between 86.6% and 89.1% of the sample. Firms switching to a woman chief executive saw return on assets rise 2.8%. Switching from a white to a non-white chief executive gained 1.3%. Switching the other way produced no comparable improvement, and that asymmetry is the whole finding.

The explanation is the door. It is heavier, so only the exceptional ones get through it. Women of color clear 2 filters rather than 1, which is precisely why they finish first.

“In a sense, we are comparing extraordinary women with average white males.”

— Sonal Kumar, Assistant Professor of Finance, Bryant University

My take: Every one of us has been handed the cheerful version of this at a diversity offsite. Women leaders outperform, put more on the board, everybody claps. The authors say directly that the finding means the opposite of how it gets used: if boards conclude that women and racialized executives succeed because of unusual qualities, they will overlook the barriers that filtered everyone else out. The outperformance is the measurement of the filter. So go look at your own promotion data, specifically the people who were nearly ready and did not get it, split by who they are. Unlike a study that ends in 2013, you can change that on a Tuesday.

🎧 Track: “Sisters Are Doin' It for Themselves” — Eurythmics and Aretha Franklin, 1985.

05 — The book 📕

It started with a San Francisco recall election

The best and most frightening thing I read this summer is Gil Durán's The Nerd Reich: Silicon Valley Fascism and the War on Democracy, out on the 18th. It began locally. San Francisco's 2022 recalls, where tech money lined up behind the moderates. Durán could not work out why that alliance existed and went looking. 4 years later the answer is a book.

“We have a government of the billionaires, by the billionaires and for the billionaires. And this is an existential crisis that we're confronting in our time.”

— Gil Durán

The through line is documented rather than inferred. Thiel wrote in 2009 that freedom and democracy were incompatible and that women's suffrage had been a mistake. He hired J.D. Vance, funded his Senate campaign and pushed for his place on the ticket. Curtis Yarvin, a blogger who wants a national dictator and a purge of the federal bureaucracy, publicly backed Thiel's 2009 position, and that purge later showed up as an actual government department. Balaji Srinivasan, funded by Thiel at 2 startups, sells the network state, which is a private country you crowdfund.

My take: I put this in a people newsletter on purpose, because it is the operating context for everything above it. If the other items feel connected without you being able to say how, this is the how. The money funding the buildout that layoffs are paying for, and the network state projects, and the argument that the professional bureaucracy should be dissolved, is held by people who have written down that they think the voting part is the problem. That is not a metaphor. Thiel published it under his own name in 2009 and never retracted it. Read the book. Then reread whatever your board deck says about the future of work, and notice which future it assumes.

🎧 Track: “Killing in the Name” — Rage Against the Machine, 1992. You wanted loud.

06 — The report card 📉

Still grading last year while this year gets away from us

Business Insider asked again this month why companies keep running annual reviews that everybody agrees do not work. The honest answer is that the review was never a development tool. It is documentation wearing a development costume, and it survives criticism it cannot answer because nobody is defending its ability to improve performance. They are defending its ability to hold up in a dispute 18 months later.

In Gallup's work, only 2% of Fortune 500 chief human resources officers strongly agreed their performance process motivated improvement. McKinsey's HR Monitor 2026, off roughly 1,300 HR professionals and 5,500 employees across 10 countries, found only 11% of organizations take a genuinely long-term view of workforce planning, 24% of employees report no training at all, and more than half get feedback once a year or never.

My take: Annual reviews, engagement surveys and meeting note takers are all lagging indicators, delivered as documents nobody acts on. Last week, last quarter, last year. Meanwhile 24% of your people did no training at all and half heard from their manager once. What you have is a timing problem, and the fix is unfashionable: skill people while the thing is happening rather than grading them for it afterwards. It costs less than the review cycle, takes less of everybody's calendar, and it is the only intervention here that changes an outcome instead of recording one. Every hour spent building next year's rating scale is an hour you did not spend on the managers who need it now.

🎧 Track: “School's Out” — Alice Cooper, 1972.

Quick hits ⚡

58% would turn down the promotion. Not over the work, over the phone. A Hint App survey of 13,742 working adults found 58% would decline if it meant answering messages after hours, 61% named work never feeling finished as the biggest downside, and 68% of 18 to 34 year olds want no part of management on those terms. Your high-potential list is a list of people who might say no. Inc. →

950,000 cut, and most of them hired back. Tech has shed more than 950,000 jobs since 2020, and Alphabet, Amazon, Apple and Netflix all sit above where they started. Visier puts rehire at 5.3%. Orgvue puts the real cost at $1.27 spent for every $1 saved. Ask for the rehire rate on your last round before anybody models the next one. Axios →

75% of managers are not ready. Paradigm surveyed HR leaders at 650+ companies. Three quarters said their managers were unprepared or only partly prepared to lead people through change of any kind, while more than half of those same companies named a major transformation as a priority. Fast Company →

🎧 Track: “Workin' for the Weekend” — Loverboy, 1981.

Field notes 🗒️

Notes for every seat, going into the last quarter

For the CEO

Ask for the rehire rate on your last reduction. Not the savings number, which somebody already put in a deck, but how many of those roles you have since refilled, backfilled, contracted out or rebuilt under a different title. Orgvue's finding that $1 of savings costs $1.27 is a sector average. Yours is knowable and nobody has been asked to produce it.

For the Founder

Write down the 3 conversations a machine will never run in your product or your company, and termination is 1 of them. Then write down who is allowed to say no to a shipping decision and tell them out loud that using it will not be held against them. A control nobody is permitted to trigger is decoration, and section 05 is what the world looks like when nobody builds one.

For the CHRO

3 things, all cheap to check. Pull every live job posting and match it to a real requisition, because a fifth of the market is running ads for nothing and New York is about to make that a fine. Find out whether any question disappeared from your engagement survey this cycle and who approved it. And get the promotion data on the people who were nearly ready and did not get it, split by who they are, because the Concordia study is describing your filter as much as anybody's.

Joanna Kmiec's line is the one to carry into October. Once you lose trust it moves more metrics than leadership gives it credit for. Everything in this issue is a trust withdrawal somebody made without pricing it.

🎧 Track: “Under Pressure” — Queen and David Bowie, 1981.


New in October 🧭

The Change Management MasterClass

Every story in this issue is a change somebody made without a plan and then handed to you to absorb. 950,000 roles cut and bought back. A pay question deleted with no explanation. Managers told to lead a transformation nobody prepared them for. That is what happens when the technology arrives before the method does.

So I am teaching the method. I am Prosci certified, I have run this on the inside as a CHRO and on the outside as a founder, and this is practical skilling rather than a framework tour. You leave able to read a change while it is happening, decide in real time, and put a conscious plan behind it instead of a launch date.

→ Session 1 · Reading the change. Who is affected, what they lose, where resistance already is
→ Session 2 · Building the plan. Sponsorship, sequencing, and the decisions you make once
→ Session 3 · Landing it. Managers, measurement, and what to do when it goes sideways in week 3

3 live sessions in October · 1PM EST · live + recorded · you build a working plan in the room · a People & Progress subscription included.

🎶 The Summertime Blues playlist

Theme · "Summertime Blues" — Eddie Cochran
Editorial · "The Boys of Summer" — Don Henley
From Kristy · "Cruel Summer" — Bananarama
01 · "Here Comes the Sun" — The Beatles
02 · "Money" — Pink Floyd
03 · "Ghost Town" — The Specials
04 · "Sisters Are Doin' It for Themselves" — Eurythmics & Aretha Franklin
05 · "Killing in the Name" — Rage Against the Machine
06 · "School's Out" — Alice Cooper
Quick hits · "Workin' for the Weekend" — Loverboy
Field notes · "Under Pressure" — Queen & David Bowie
MasterClass · "Changes" — David Bowie
Closer · "September" — Earth, Wind & Fire

13 tracks for the last weekend of it. Windows down, volume up, and forward it to somebody who spent this summer applying to jobs that were never there. 🔊

The takeaway 🌅

Answer somebody

Read the issue back and the same thing happens in every story. A person asks, and the building does not answer. 3,000 applications into ads that were never jobs. A pay question removed from a survey. 950,000 people cut and most of them bought back at a premium.

Eddie Cochran got the ending right in 1958. Every institution in that song has a reply ready, and the reply is always a version of not you, not now. The only thing that has changed is that some of the people funding the current arrangement have started saying in public that the asking part was the mistake.

The assignment for the last quarter is short and it costs nothing. Answer somebody. Take down the postings that are not real. Tell the person who did not get the job. Put the pay question back in the survey and publish what comes back. Tell your managers what the evenings cost them and then fix it. None of that is transformation and none of it will make a conference stage.

Somebody is waiting on an answer from you right now. Give them one before September.

See you next week. Keep building the good stuff. 🐾

— Kristy

🎧 Track: “September” — Earth, Wind & Fire, 1978. Ba-dee-ya.

127 Ventures

💌 People & Progress is free, ungated, and always will be. Subscribe here - Home | The People & Progress Report, then send it to somebody who spent this summer waiting on an answer.

© 2026 Kristy McCann Flynn · 127 Ventures. Real Leadership. Real Results.
[Unsubscribe] · [Manage preferences] · [Read past issues]